Cal Kellogg boxed a limit of pound-and-a-half to 3 pound rainbows at Collins Lake in cold, rainy January conditions. Water was high 40s at 48 degrees with about 2 feet of visibility, so bait fishing shallow beat trolling. Keep garlic PowerBait in 15 feet of water or less and spike it with Power Powder for extra scent. Give each spot 30 to 45 minutes before making a short move.
What is biting at Collins Lake right now?
Rainbow trout, and the quality is strong. Cal Kellogg landed a ten-fish limit of pan-sized to 3 pound rainbows through rain and wind. No giants this trip, but a solid grade of clean, good-eating fish.
How deep are the trout at Collins Lake in January?
Shallow. Everything came in 15 feet of water or less, and shallower was clearly better in the cold water. With the water in the high 40s, the fish are not chasing, so keep your bait up in the top of the column.
Bait or trolling at Collins Lake right now?
Bait fishing wins in these cold, stained conditions. Cal could pick a few off on the troll during the midday temperature spike, but he could not match the numbers he gets on bait. If you want to fill a limit, soak bait shallow and be patient.
What bait and scent is working?
Garlic PowerBait carried the day, mostly in Rainbow. Cal spikes his dough with Power Powder to load extra scent and bite stimulant into the water, which is key in cold, low-visibility conditions. Fish a slack line and let them run with it before you set the hook.
What were the conditions at Collins Lake?
Cold and wet. Water temperature high 40s at 48 degrees, about 2 to 2 and a half feet of visibility, with wind upwelling colder water. Cal had to tie off to a tree because he could not double-anchor in the wind.
Cal's outlook for Collins Lake
Fish are scattered all over the lake and every spot produced action. Work three or four spots without leaving the bay, give each 30 to 45 minutes, and make short moves. As afternoon sun warms the surface, trolling becomes a real option too.
Watch the full report
Collins Lake January 7, 2025 FAQ
Keep your bait in 15 feet of water or less. Shallower is better in cold, high-40s water.
Garlic PowerBait in Rainbow, spiked with Power Powder by Cal Kellogg for extra scent and bite stimulant.
High 40s, 48 degrees at launch, with about 2 to 2 and a half feet of visibility.
Bait fishing out-produces trolling in cold, stained conditions. Trolling can pick up a few fish during the midday warm-up.
Give each spot 30 to 45 minutes. If it does not produce, make a short move of a few hundred yards rather than a long run.
Capt. Cal Kellogg, a veteran Northern California trout and salmon guide.







