Eagle Lake trout are biting steadily in late October 2025 despite hail, rain, and wind. Fish are holding in the top few feet over 20 to 40 feet of open water, not yet in the shallows. Run J-Fair trolling flies on top-line rigs, with hot orange the standout color. A new water-based Fly Spray in Minnow Mayhem keeps marabou fluffing naturally and outfished unscented flies in a same-day test.
What is biting at Eagle Lake right now?
Trout, and plenty of them. The Catch America crew landed a lot of fish through hail, rain, and wind on their late October trips. Fish are up in the top few feet of the water column, holding over 20 to 40 feet of open water rather than crowding the shallows so far.
What depth are the trout holding at Eagle Lake?
Right up in the surface few feet, but positioned over 20 to 40 feet of open water. There have not been many fish in the shallows yet. The cooling trend is expected to push trout shallow soon for a classic fall Eagle Lake bite.
What flies and colors work at Eagle Lake in fall?
J-Fair trolling flies on top-line rigs, with hot orange doing most of the damage. Orange is predominantly a strong color at Eagle Lake. A few fish came on other colors, but the trout clearly wanted orange on this day.
What scent is being used on the flies?
A new water-based Fly Spray in the Minnow Mayhem formula. Because it is water-based, it does not pack down the marabou like oil-based scents, so the feathers still fluff in the water. In a same-day test, the scented flies outperformed the unscented ones.
What is the outlook for Eagle Lake?
Strong. The crew is fishing the rest of the week through more funky weather, and the fish are biting with a lot of bent rods. The cooler trend should push trout into the shallows for a traditional fall bite. Only a few guide days remain for late October into early November.
Watch the full report
Eagle Lake October 2025 FAQ
Hot orange did most of the damage. Orange is predominantly a strong color at Eagle Lake.
Up in the top few feet of the surface, holding over 20 to 40 feet of open water.
Run J-Fair trolling flies on top-line rigs near the surface.
Yes. The water-based Minnow Mayhem Fly Spray keeps marabou fluffy and outfished unscented flies in a same-day test.
Tui chub minnows, which is why the minnow-imitating scent and flies are producing.
Not many. Fish are still over open water, but a cooling trend should push them shallow soon.
The guide is not named in this report. It comes from the Catch America fall fly trolling trips.







