Skip to content

Lake Berryessa Fishing Report | December 4, 2025

Report by Capt. Nate Kelsch (Big Nate)
Nate Kelsch runs Big Nate's Guide Service on Lake Berryessa and is a Catch America pro-staff captain. Cal Kellogg joined him for this soft plastic test. Shop Nate Kelsch (Big Nate)'s tackle.
What is working right now

The soft plastic bite is popping at Lake Berryessa in December 2025. Capt. Nate Kelsch and Cal Kellogg trolled Trout Trix Minnows, the new Trix Minnow XL, and Trix Worms, with a couple of Trigger Spoons out too. About 17 to 20 hookups on big Eagle Lake strain rainbows through a foggy morning.

What is biting at Lake Berryessa right now?

Big rainbow trout, including chunky Eagle Lake strain fish, are piling up on soft plastics. Capt. Nate Kelsch reported 17 to 20 hookups and steady action, with several large fish landed. Nate came out skeptical of the plastics and left smacking them all morning.

What lures are working at Lake Berryessa in December?

Trolled soft plastics are the story: Trout Trix Minnows in regular and shad or minnow colors, a chartreuse minnow, the new Trix Minnow XL, and a pink Trix Worm. A couple of Trigger Spoons were also in the spread.

What depth were the fish holding at Lake Berryessa?

Nate ran the soft plastics on downriggers to reach the trout. A specific depth was not specified in this report. The morning started slow behind a solid wall of fog before the plastic bite turned on and the fish stacked up.

How is Nate presenting the soft plastics?

Slow-troll the soft plastic minnows and worms behind the boat on downriggers. Nate notes the hook loops around the fish's lower jaw so they do not get away. He ran new prototypes alongside older Trix Minnows and worms and caught fish on all of them.

What is the outlook for Lake Berryessa?

Nate says the soft plastic game has changed things at Berryessa, with big fish and steady action. Cal Kellogg notes soft plastics work worldwide because they look and feel real. The bite was popping loose the day of this report, with the lake producing well.

Watch the full report

From the report (Capt. Nate Kelsch (Big Nate)): We just put in some Trout Trix Minnow, just a regular size one, and then we put in one of our new ones, slightly larger, different colorations. We also have a couple of Trigger Spoons out. We got about 17 to 20 hookups already. Not just a couple fish. We got big fish. The soft plastic bite is popping loose here at Berryessa.

Lake Berryessa December 4, 2025 FAQ

What are the best baits for Lake Berryessa trout in December?

Trolled soft plastics: Trout Trix Minnows, the Trix Minnow XL, and Trix Worms, plus a couple of Trigger Spoons.

What colors worked at Lake Berryessa?

A shad or minnow pattern, a chartreuse minnow, and a pink worm all produced fish in this report.

How many fish did they catch at Lake Berryessa?

Roughly 17 to 20 hookups on the day, including several big Eagle Lake strain rainbows.

What depth were the trout at Lake Berryessa?

A specific depth was not specified in this report. The soft plastics were run on downriggers.

Do soft plastics catch trout while trolling?

Yes. Nate started skeptical and ended up smacking big trout on Trout Trix minnows and worms. Cal Kellogg notes soft plastics look and feel real, so fish grab and hold on.

Who guides Lake Berryessa for Catch America?

Capt. Nate Kelsch (Big Nate) of Big Nate's Guide Service, out with Cal Kellogg for this trip.

Previous Post Next Post